29 Jan 2026

During nationwide consultations on establishing a Constitutional Court, councillors in Kanye expressed a mix of support and pointed criticisms regarding the proposal’s process, timing, and potential implications.

The consultations held Monday at Tomela council chamber were led by Minister of Justice Mr Nelson Ramaotwana. While ruling party-aligned councillors largely welcomed the initiative, others raised significant concerns.

Councillor Shimane Thelo of Lotlhakane East/Diabo questioned the urgency of the reform amid pressing national priorities. He highlighted the substantial financial costs of setting up and maintaining a specialised court, suggesting that resources would be better allocated to urgent issues such as healthcare, unemployment, and service delivery.

Some councillors also expressed worries about risks of judicial overreach or politicisation, which could potentially undermine rather than strengthen the independence of the judiciary. Despite these reservations, many councillors commended Minister Ramaotwana for his clear and accessible presentation.

They praised his ability to explain complex legal concepts in relatable terms, which helped address initial doubts and foster understanding. They appreciated his patient, direct engagement with questions and his consultative approach.

Several councillors noted that the minister’s emphasis on the court’s advantages such as faster resolution of constitutional matters, reduced backlog pressure on the High Court, and enhanced protections for citizens’ rights, aligned well with local governance priorities.

The discussion reflected considerable enthusiasm among many attendees, who described the proposal as a forward-thinking reform consistent with Botswana’s democratic values.

Others highlighted the minister’s transparent handling of the process and his direct involvement in district-level consultations as evidence of genuine commitment to inclusive dialogue.

In response, Minister Ramaotwana stressed that each sector of government has distinct responsibilities and urged citizens to segregate and address issues within their relevant ministries, for instance, health matters should be directed to the Ministry of Health.

He explained that his ministry operates under specific targets and priorities, one of which was the establishment of the Constitutional Court within the current administration’s five-year term. Mr Ramaotwana described Botswana as a progressive nation whose development spans all sectors, including judicial structures as part of broader transformation.

He reiterated that the consultations aimed to gather diverse input and build consensus, emphasising the court’s role in bolstering human rights protections and judicial efficiency as a progressive advancement.

The Kanye session underscores emerging divisions in the national debate, with enthusiastic local support in some quarters contrasting with scepticism or opposition elsewhere. As consultations continue through mid-February 2026, these varied perspectives are expected to influence the trajectory of any proposed constitutional amendment. BOPA